Connors Robert J.” The Erasure of the Sentence”CCC vol. 52 No. September 2000. 95-128.
He claims that contemporary composition dismisses the sentence based pedagogies of the 60s and 70s. In the summary of this article he states: "The usefulness of these sentence-based rhetoric was never disproved, but a growing wave of anti-formalism, anti-behaviorist, and anti-empiricism within English-based composition studies after 1980 dooms to them to a marginality under which they still exist today. “ He claims the imitation of excellent writers actually improve students’ writing.
Donovan, Timothy R. and
Ben W. McClelland. ed. Eight Approaches to Teaching Composition. Illinois: NCTE, 1980. Print.
The book
is a practical but not how-to-teach book. The collection of articles analyzes composition theories from many fields of language studies such as
rhetoric.
France,
Alan W. Dialects of self: “Structure and
Agency as the Subject of English.”
College English Vol. 63 No. 2. November 2000 pp145-165. Print.
College English Vol. 63 No. 2. November 2000 pp145-165. Print.
He
argues contemporary composition theory appears to focus on self as an
independent agency not connected to cultural context. He delineates his points through his own classroom assignments.
“In
Composition, methodological individualism means that our pedagogy idealizes the
seemingly untutored “”authentic” expression of personal experience, a “writing
without teachers” to use Peter Elbow’s koine, which, proper as it is as a final
objective is clearly not a good foundation for developing a common rhetorical
pedagogy for English literature and language skills” (147).
Porter, Kevin J. "A Pedagogy of Charity: Donald Davidson and the Student-Negotiated
Composition Classroom.” CCC .The Journal
of the Conference on College Composition and Communication National Council of
Teachers of English Vol. 52 No. 4 June 2001.
P547-611 Print.
The
author labels traditional method of composition teaching a pedagogy of severity
that centers around the discussion of faults and problems – it is easier - and calls for a pedagogy of
charity. He argues that the charitable
attitude motivates students to produce better revisions.
No comments:
Post a Comment